You are currently viewing Non Traditional Engagement Rings: The Ultimate Review of 5 Standout Pieces

Non Traditional Engagement Rings: The Ultimate Review of 5 Standout Pieces

  • Post last modified:2 May 2024

Beyond the Ordinary: Introducing Non Traditional Engagement Rings

Have you ever felt the thrill of discovering something truly unique, something that speaks to you on a personal level?

That’s the magic we’re diving into today with the world of non traditional engagement rings. It’s not just about stepping away from the conventional; it’s about embracing a piece that mirrors your individuality and the distinct love you share with your partner.

Think about it – when you picture an engagement ring, what comes to mind? If you’re like many of us, you might envision a classic diamond solitaire.

Beautiful, yes, but not for everyone. Now, imagine a ring that breaks all the moulds, one that tells a story as unique as yours. That’s where non-traditional engagement rings come into play.

I’m excited to share with you not just any rings but five standout pieces from renowned jewellers. Each one of these rings challenges the norms, showcasing the beauty of going beyond the ordinary.

Why settle for something traditional when you can wear a symbol of your love that’s as unique as your relationship?

This journey we’re about to embark on isn’t just about viewing different rings; it’s about discovering how each piece can reflect the essence of who you are and the bond you share.

From the captivating allure of unconventional designs to the personal statements they make, non-traditional engagement rings offer a world of possibilities.

So, are you ready to explore this fascinating realm with me? Let’s uncover the stories these rings tell and, perhaps, inspire the next chapter of your own love story.

Join me as we celebrate uniqueness, quality, and the art of standing out. After all, in a world full of diamonds, being a little different is how you truly shine.

Crafting Uniqueness: Blue Nile’s Non Traditional Engagement Rings

In the quest for the perfect non traditional engagement rings, two names stand out as pioneers in the jewellery world: Blue Nile and James Allen.

Have you ever wondered what sets them apart in the bustling online jewellery market? It’s not just their vast collections that draw the eye but their unwavering commitment to quality and customer satisfaction that truly makes them shine.

Let’s start with Blue Nile. Imagine a place where every click brings you closer to finding that one-of-a-kind ring. That’s Blue Nile for you. They revolutionized the way we shop for engagement rings, placing the power of choice right at your fingertips.

What’s fascinating about Blue Nile is not just their array of options but their dedication to guiding you through the journey of finding a ring that’s as unique as your love story.

Now, onto James Allen. Have you ever wanted to design a ring that no one else has? James Allen says, “Why not?” With their innovative 360° technology, you can inspect every gemstone up close and personal, ensuring your non-traditional engagement ring is everything you dreamed of and more.

Their service is like having a jeweller in your living room, ready to customize your ring to the smallest detail.

Both Blue Nile and James Allen share a commitment to creating unforgettable moments with their non-traditional engagement rings. Whether it’s through their exceptional craftsmanship, personalized services, or the sheer variety of designs, they ensure that your ring stands out from the crowd.

Their collections are a testament to the fact that engagement rings don’t have to be traditional to symbolize deep love and commitment. They prove that quality, innovation, and customer satisfaction are the true gems in the world of non-traditional engagement rings.

So, as we dive deeper into the unique selections of Blue Nile and James Allen, remember that the ring you choose is more than a piece of jewellery.

It’s a reflection of your journey, your love, and the uniqueness that defines you. With these giants by your side, you’re not just choosing a ring; you’re embracing a piece of art that tells your story.

A Symphony of Gems: The Topaz Cocktail Ring from Blue Nile


Behold the vibrant dance of colours with this London Blue and Swiss Blue Topaz Cocktail Ring, a testament to non-traditional engagement rings that dare to defy the ordinary. Set in warm 14k yellow gold, this ring parades a grand London Blue Topaz, its deep oceanic hue enigmatic and full of stories.

Accompanying this majestic centrepiece are the light-hearted Swiss Blue Topazes, which look like clear skies on a summer day. The ring is also available in different colour stones, such as Peridot, exuding a lush, earthy glow, and it is a multicolour option for those who revel in a kaleidoscope of hues. The choice of metal is just as personalized, with options in both 14k yellow and rose gold to match your individual style.

Price Range:

Offered between £818 – £1018, the ring’s value dances with the light and colours of its precious gemstones. Each variation, be it the tranquil Peridot or the exuberant Multicolour, is expertly crafted to suit your personal narrative.

Standout Feature:

What truly sets this ring apart in the realm of non-traditional engagement rings is its celebration of colour and composition. Beyond the traditional single-stone centrepiece, this ring harmonizes multiple gems that sing in unison. The diamond accents are the final chorus, adding a touch of timeless elegance to a modern melody. This ring isn’t just a piece of jewellery; it’s a statement of sophistication and individuality, perfect for the modern romantic who is not bound by tradition but inspired by it.

Romance Reimagined: The Vintage Floral Engraved Halo Ring from Blue Nile


Step into a timeless love story with the Vintage Floral Engraved Halo Ring, a piece where elegance and nostalgia gracefully intertwine. This enchanting ring from Blue Nile, crafted in the choice of 14k white, yellow, and rose gold, as well as 18k variants and even platinum, caters to every preference with a touch of luxury. The round centre stone is cradled by a halo, not just of brilliance but of artistry, with vintage floral engravings that whisper tales of yesteryears and dreams of forever.

Price Range:

With a price range spanning from £1,120 to £1,646, this ring’s value lies not only in its material but in the meticulous craftsmanship and everlasting design. Whether it’s the warm hues of rose gold that catch your fancy or the timeless prestige of platinum, each choice offers its own narrative of romance.

Standout Feature:

What truly distinguishes this non-traditional engagement ring is the fusion of classic charm with modern sensibilities. The halo is not just a setting; it’s a canvas showcasing the intricate milgrain detail reminiscent of an artist’s delicate brushstrokes. This ring doesn’t simply sparkle; it sings a sonnet of the past, making it an ideal symbol for those who carry a vintage heart in the contemporary world. It’s for the romantic souls who see their bonds as a tapestry woven with the threads of tradition and the vibrancy of the present.

Enchanting Hues: The Romantic Marquise Pink Sapphire and Diamond Ring from Blue Nile


The Romantic Marquise Pink Sapphire and Diamond Ring is a celebration of love in vivid colour, a distinctive choice from Blue Nile’s non-traditional engagement rings. The ring’s band in 14k rose gold offers a warm embrace to the marquise-cut pink sapphires that dance across the finger. These precious stones are alternated with brilliant round-cut diamonds, creating a rhythmic beauty that captivates the eye. This ring also shines in the cool lustre of platinum, providing a luxurious alternative for those who are drawn to the timeless allure of this rare metal.

Price Range:

Valued between £1,802 and £2,252, this ring is a testament to craftsmanship and design, where each gemstone is meticulously set to celebrate an everlasting bond.

Standout Feature:

Its standout feature is undoubtedly the delicate balance of the soft pink sapphires with the classic sparkle of diamonds, creating a visual sonnet that speaks of romantic whispers and eternal promises. The design’s allure is its blend of feminine grace with a touch of modernity, making it a perfect emblem of a love that’s both deep-rooted and ever-blooming. For the admirer of beauty who seeks a symbol of affection as rare and profound as their own romance, this ring is more than an accessory—it’s a pledge written in the language of jewels.

Iridescent Elegance: The Oval Opal and Swiss Blue Topaz Halo Ring from Blue Nile


Capturing the enchanting play of colours that only nature can conceive, the Oval Opal and Swiss Blue Topaz Halo Ring from the Blue Nile is a dream woven into reality. Crafted in the tender blush of 14k rose gold, the ring spotlights an alluring oval opal, its surface alive with an ethereal dance of colours. Encircling this centrepiece is a double halo of vivid Swiss blue topaz and sparkling white sapphires reminiscent of clear blue skies cradling the opalescent clouds at sunset.


Priced at £1,093, this ring is an accessible treasure, a piece of the celestial tapestry that you can call your own.

Standout Feature:

This non-traditional engagement ring is distinguished by its spectral luminescence, a feature that promises to turn heads with its mesmerizing hues. The opal, celebrated for its kaleidoscopic brilliance, is offset by the clear blue and white gems, creating a harmonious balance that’s perfect for special occasions. As opals are softer gemstones, they carry with them an air of preciousness and care suited for those who value the rare and remarkable in life, just like their choice in love.

Cool Radiance: The Pear-Shaped Aquamarine Fashion Ring from Blue Nile


The Pear-Shaped Aquamarine Fashion Ring from Blue Nile captures the essence of a tranquil sea, with its serene aquamarine stone cut in a graceful pear shape. This gemstone, reminiscent of the ocean’s heart, is ensconced within a radiant halo of diamonds, all resting on a band of pristine 14k white gold. The piece exudes a sophistication that’s understated yet compelling, much like the depth of the sea it represents.


At £2,135, this ring is a statement of elegance, promising to be a cherished piece for those who are drawn to the cool allure of aquamarine, the birthstone of March.

Standout Feature:

What makes this ring an extraordinary pick for a non traditional engagement ring is the distinct teardrop silhouette of the aquamarine, symbolizing tears of joy and the depth of emotion. The surrounding diamonds enhance the aquamarine’s natural brilliance, ensuring that this ring isn’t just an accessory but a beacon of the wearer’s unique essence. It’s designed for those who hold a reverence for beauty, depth, and the unconventional path to matrimonial bliss.

FAQ: Your Non Traditional Engagement Ring Questions Answered

What defines a ring as ‘non-traditional’ in terms of engagement?

Non traditional engagement rings break away from the classic diamond solitaire setting. They can feature alternative gemstones, unique designs, varied metals, or even personal embellishments that reflect individual styles and values.

Are non traditional engagement rings less expensive than traditional ones?

Not necessarily. The price of non traditional engagement rings can vary widely based on materials, gemstone quality, and design complexity. They can be more affordable or even pricier than traditional options, depending on these factors.

How do I choose the right size for a non traditional engagement ring?

Many online jewellers offer sizing guides. You can also visit a local jeweller to get your ring size measured accurately. If it’s a surprise, you might try to measure a ring that the recipient currently wears on the same finger.

Can non traditional engagement rings be resized?

Yes, many non-traditional engagement rings can be resized. However, the ease of resizing will depend on the design and material of the ring. It’s best to check with the jeweller before purchasing if you anticipate needing resizing.

What types of gemstones are commonly used in non traditional engagement rings?

Aside from diamonds, popular choices include sapphires, rubies, emeralds, opals, morganite, aquamarine, and even pearls. The choice of gemstone often reflects the wearer’s birthstone, favourite colour, or the gem’s unique meaning.

How do I care for my non traditional engagement ring?

Care will vary depending on the materials. Generally, gentle cleaning with mild soap and warm water and using a soft brush is safe for most rings. Be sure to dry it thoroughly. For specific gemstone care, consult your jeweller for advice.

Is it safe to buy a non-traditional engagement ring online?

Yes, purchasing rings online is safe, especially from reputable retailers like Blue Nile and James Allen. They offer detailed images, certifications, and return policies to ensure a secure and satisfying purchase.

What should I look for in terms of quality when buying a non traditional engagement ring?

Look for high-quality gemstones with a good cut, clarity, and colour. The metal should be durable—typically 14k or 18k gold, platinum, or palladium. Ensure that the setting is secure, especially if it has multiple stones.

Do non traditional engagement rings hold their value?

Like all fine jewellery, the value retention of non-traditional engagement rings depends on the quality and rarity of the materials used, as well as the ring’s condition over time.

Can I customize a non traditional engagement ring at Blue Nile or James Allen?

Absolutely! Both Blue Nile and James Allen offer customization services that allow you to create a ring that truly reflects your personal style and love story.

Crafting Your Unique Symbol of Love: Choosing the Right Non Traditional Engagement Ring

Selecting the perfect non-traditional engagement ring is an intimate art form—it’s about finding the piece that resonates with the wearer’s soul. Here’s some advice to guide you through this exhilarating process:

Reflect on Personality and Style:

Your ring should be an extension of the wearer’s personality. Are they bold and avant-garde, or do they lean towards understated elegance? Their everyday style can inspire the ring’s design—whether it’s flamboyant, adorned with colourful gemstones, or minimalistic with subtle details.

Consider Lifestyle and Comfort:

Think about the daily routine. A ring with a high-set gemstone might not be ideal for someone with an active lifestyle, while a bezel setting could be perfect for its sleekness and security. A comfort-fit band is also worth considering for those who aren’t used to wearing rings.

Choose a Meaningful Gemstone:

Beyond diamonds, there’s a whole spectrum of gemstones that can add personal significance to a ring. Birthstones, gems with particular meanings, or colours that hold special significance to the wearer can make the ring truly theirs.

Decide on the metal:

The metal not only contributes to the ring’s aesthetics but also to its longevity. Platinum and palladium are durable and hypoallergenic, while gold offers a classic allure with options in white, yellow, or rose hues. The right choice balances beauty with practicality.

Ponder Design Intricacies:

From the band’s silhouette to the setting’s architecture, every design choice crafts a story. Engravings, vintage inspirations, or contemporary lines—each detail contributes to the ring’s narrative.

Evaluate Gemstone Durability:

Not all gemstones are created equal, especially when it comes to hardness. If the ring will be worn daily, consider stones that stand up well to wear and tear, like sapphires or rubies. Softer stones like opals may require more care.

Think of the Future:

An engagement ring is a long-term investment. Consider how the design will age and if it can be easily resized or modified if needed.

Trust Your Instincts:

Sometimes, the right ring just feels right. Trust your gut feeling when you come across a design that simply feels like ‘the one.’

By considering these aspects, you’re well on your way to selecting a non-traditional engagement ring that celebrates the wearer’s uniqueness, ensuring that when they slip it on their finger, it feels like a faithful companion, a true representation of their individual essence and your shared love.

Embracing Individuality: The Final Word on Non Traditional Engagement Rings

As we close the curtain on our exploration of non-traditional engagement rings, we circle back to the heart of what makes these treasures so extraordinary.

It’s not just about the unconventional gemstones, the innovative designs, or the bold statements made by each ring. It’s about the way these rings mirror the unique beauty and the personal journey of the individuals who wear them.

The featured pieces from Blue Nile, each with their own story and character, remind us that there’s no single definition of the perfect ring. Whether it’s the whimsical charm of an opal halo, the serene elegance of aquamarine, or the passionate hues of pink sapphire, these rings are about expressing your own narrative of love.

As you embark on the quest to find the best non traditional engagement rings, let your imagination lead the way. Embrace your quirks, your preferences, and your dreams. Remember, an engagement ring doesn’t just signify the promise of a shared future; it’s a reflection of the deep, individual connection between two souls.

So, dare to defy expectations. Choose a ring that’s as unique as your fingerprint, as enduring as your bond, and as brilliant as your love story. Because when it comes to celebrating love, the only tradition that matters is the one you create together.

Thank you for joining me on this journey through the world of vintage non traditional engagement rings. May your engagement ring be as unique as your love, as timeless as your commitment, and as joyful as your brightest day together.

Explore More on Engagement Rings

If you’ve found our article helpful, you may be interested in further exploring the world of engagement rings. Below is a curated list of articles that delve into various styles and aspects of engagement rings. Each link offers unique insights and detailed information that could be just what you’re looking for: